Christian and Feminist?

Perhaps a little historical context is in order. Beginning nearly a hundred years ago as the women’s suffrage movement, feminism has perhaps been the most influential cultural development of the past century. A direct line can be traced from suffrage to prohibition in the 20s to the civil rights movement of the 50s and 60s to the women’s liberation movement of the 70s.

Men have had to change the way they think about women, and – perhaps more importantly – women have had to change the way they think about themselves. And, in the process, regardless of how you feel about the word “feminism”, it must be conceded that valuable and legitimate contributions have been made.

Ironically, the contemporary feminist movement has its roots in Evangelical Christianity. Most of the early pioneers of women’s suffrage were committed Christians. It was because of their religious beliefs (not in spite of them) that they worked towards greater equality for women.

Susan B. Anthony, for instance, was a committed Christian, having grown up in a Quaker family that instilled in her a strong devotion to Jesus and, as a result, to the pursuit of justice. She campaigned tirelessly for the abolition of slavery and for the full citizenship of black people — including their right to vote. This was in the 1820s, by the way. She also argued in favor of co-education, claiming that women were able to learn just as well as men. She worked for child labor laws and for the rights of women in the workplace. She was also staunchly opposed to abortion — which is, sadly, a stance that few feminists share today.

However, she realized that her opinions would never be taken seriously until women had the right to vote. And so she devoted the next half century to the women’s suffrage movement.

If feminism is defined as “a belief in and commitment to the full equality of men and women in home, church, and society” (this is from feminist theologians Letha Scanzoni and Nancy Hardesty), it would seem that feminism is rooted in a value system drawn from a Judeo-Christian worldview — which places men and women on equal status and stresses the inherent dignity of each human life.

Historically speaking, the ideas and ideals of Christianity and Feminism have hardly been mutually exclusive. That’s a fairly recent development. In fact, a good case can be made that one (Feminism) initially grew out of the other (Christianity). It seems now that most Feminists aren’t very fond of most Christians and most Christians are afraid of most Feminists.

Why do you suppose it’s so hard to get the two sides together now?

7 Responses to “Christian and Feminist?”

  1. iz Says:

    I grew up in a denomination that evolved from an identity of more who we were “not” (or did not do) rather than who we “were” (what we did do or believe in). Many groups struggle to find secure identity when you base your foundation on a reactionary process as opposed to being proactive in who and what you are. This also leads to vulnerability and greater intimidation from others questioning your position/beliefs.

  2. Wendy Says:

    I think many churches are distinctly patriarchal and limiting to women. My husband was appalled at how the church I worked for (as church secretary) treated me. Women are definitely still second class citizens in most churches. So most feminists want nothing to do with an institution that oppresses women.

  3. Gallagher Says:

    It may be hard to get the two sides together because we are people separate by two different agendas, yet hainv some of the same things in common, but having our similarities overshadowed by our differences.

    Sounds like just more of a people driven problem.

    Just my opinion.

  4. Terry Says:

    I really hear what Wendy is saying. And the point a lot of women are making is Jesus wouldn’t act that way toward women, so why is the Bride of Christ acting that way. Sort of puts you on the defensive and women are seeking harmony in Christ.

  5. jenksym Says:

    Ok, I know it makes me a nerd and it also makes me a little less than intellectual enough for this site; BUT after reading this I have the song from Mary Poppins running through my head.
    “Our daughters daughters will adore us
    and they’ll sing in grateful chorus . . . “

  6. John Alan Turner Says:

    Wow…jenksym…there’s an email address I haven’t seen in a very long time!

  7. Smockity Frocks Says:

    Christians are to love our neighbors as ourselves, whether they be men, women, children, Christian, Jew, Muslim, etc.

    Feminists seem to want to elevate the interests of women ABOVE others. Especially those most vulnerable and helpless, the unborn.

    That doesn’t seem to be stressing the inherent dignity of each human life to me.